Mattel Reviews

Mattel has an overall rating of 1.3 based on 21 reviews. Customer feedback on Mattel is mixed.

1.3/5.0

21 reviews

5 Stars

0

4 Stars

1

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

3

1 Star

17

All Mattel Reviews (21)
evelyn1989
May 07, 2026
"Box arrived crushed and I don’t really trust this anymore"
The box showed up crushed and halfway open, with the corners ripped like it had been kicked around before it even got to me. it made a really bad impression. I expected better packaging and care, and now I don’t feel like I can trust ordering this again. Not happy at all...
TaraTong_69
May 04, 2026
"Shipping made it not worth it"
I was just trying to buy one small toy, but the shipping was almost the same price as the item itself. At that point it just felt silly to go through with it. I know companies always dress it up with polished wording about fees and delivery options, but from my side it was simple: the total cost didn’t make sense. I probably won’t bother ordering from mattel.com for something small again.
howardminnis5069
April 15, 2026
"I ordered from mattel thinking it…"
I ordered from mattel thinking it would get here quick, but the shipping was really slow. The tracking barely updated, so I was kind of left guessing most of the time. It finally showed up much later than I expected. I probably won’t order from here again if I need the item by certain date.
Pamela-anderson
April 10, 2026
"Not quite the Mattel I had in my head"
I grew up with Mattel stuff, so I probably went in expecting too much, honestly. Seeing some of the old names and brands was cool for a minute, but the actual shopping part felt kind of clunky, like I had to poke around more than I should just to find things.

Maybe it’s just nostalgia messing with me, but it didn’t really have that fun, magic feeling I remembered. Prices felt a bit high too, which didn’t help. I wanted to enjoy it more than I did, but yeah, I came away a little disappointed
Edwin.lechler
April 07, 2026
"Felt let down"
I bought this toy thinking it would hold up at least a little while, but it broke after just two days. The plastic felt really cheap, and the wheels kept popping off over and over. I felt kind of ignored as a customer because this wasn’t at all what I expected, and it doesn’t seem like much care went into the quality
julie.Dabe
March 30, 2026
"Looked fun at first, but didn’t last"
I bought this toy from Mattel thinking it would keep my kid entertained for a while, but they were over it in about 10 minutes. It looks nice and all, but once you open it, there just isn’t much to actually do with it. For the price, I expected a lot more play value. The whole experience also felt kind of impersonal, like there wasn’t really a real person behind it, just a checkout and a box showing up.
QUEZADA
March 28, 2026
"Not Worth Ordering Direct"
I ordered from Mattel thinking it would be easier and maybe a little better than buying from other stores, but it was kind of frustrating. The toy was already more expensive than I expected, and then shipping pushed it even higher. I also had a basic request that felt like it was just ignored, which made the whole experience more annoying than it needed to be. When the package showed up, it wasn’t anything special either—just regular packaging and the same kind of quality I’ve seen for less elsewhere. I don’t really see the value in ordering direct from them, so next time I’ll definitely check other shops first
ophelia_Maldonado92
March 25, 2026
"Am I the Only One Who Found This Misleading?"
Am I the only one who gets frustrated when a toy says it’s right for your kid’s age, but then it clearly isn’t? I bought one from mattel, and it had all these tiny parts and was way too hard for my child to use. It ended up being more annoying than fun, and it definitely made me second-guess trusting the age recommendation next time.
PhillipKennedy
March 12, 2026
"Not quite what I expected from Mattel"
I went on Mattel thinking I’d knock out a few gift ideas easily, but it didn’t really turn out that way. A lot of the toys I had in mind were either missing or sold out, and after a while it felt like I was scrolling past the same things over and over. For a brand that big, I guess I just thought there’d be more to choose from.
juan_Lewis88
March 12, 2026
"Tracking Was Useless and My Plans Got Ruined"
I kept checking the tracking thinking my package was actually on the way, but it was basically useless. It never gave me a clear update, and I still haven’t received anything. I had plans around this delivery and ended up wasting my time waiting for a package that never showed up. Really frustrating.
douglasseng8256
March 06, 2026
"Limited Drops Disappear Way Too Fast"
I’ve started to notice the same pattern every time there’s a limited edition drop: I’m ready, I add it to my cart, the site starts dragging, and then suddenly it’s sold out before I can even finish checkout. It’s frustrating to wait around for something and still end up with nothing. At this point, it feels like regular customers don’t really have much of a shot.
ErinFunk
March 01, 2026
"Charged Twice, Took Longer Than Expected"
I was surprised to see my card get charged twice, since I expected the payment process to go smoothly. Support did eventually fix it, which I appreciate, but it took longer than I thought it should. Not the worst experience, but definitely a bit frustrating.
travis_Arnett02
February 12, 2026
"Slow support and not much help"
I had a frustrating experience with customer service. It took way too long for them to get back to me, and I had to keep following up myself, which gets old fast. When they finally did reply, it didn’t really fix the issue or give me much to work with. Not exactly what I was expecting, and yeah, kind of disappointing
Jeremy-cole
February 07, 2026
"I ordered a toy set from mattel…"
I ordered a toy set from mattel for my child, and at first it looked perfectly fine out of the box. But one of the plastic pieces snapped the very same day, and it wasn’t from rough play or anything unusual, just normal kid use. For the price, I expected it to hold up better. When a company makes toys for children, I feel like there’s a responsibility to make them sturdy enough that kids can actually enjoy them. Now half the set isn’t usable, and my kid was really upset. I don’t think I’ll be buying from them again if the quality is this fragile.
kelvin-Steiner
January 26, 2026
"Putting it together was rough"
I ordered a toy from mattel.com the assembly was a pain. At first I thought it would be a quick little project, but no, actually it ended up taking way longer than I expected. The instructions were super tiny and kind of confusing, and a few pieces just didn’t seem to line up right. I had to take parts back apart and redo them a couple times, which got old fast. The toy itself is fine, I guess, but the whole setup process was frustrating enough that I’d probably avoid anything from them that needs assembly next time
mia-Culler
January 13, 2026
"The return process itself was simple, which…"
The return process itself was simple, which I appreciated, but I felt a bit misled about how long the refund would take. I was expecting it to show up much sooner based on what I was told, but it ended up taking forever to appear. Not the worst experience, but definitely frustrating.
hello_ashley366
January 01, 2026
"Checkout issues made me lose confidence"
I tried placing an order twice, but the checkout kept crashing right when I got to payment. One time my cart even emptied on its own, which made me uneasy about continuing. I’m careful when it comes to online payments, so after that I didn’t really feel comfortable trying again. it was more hassle than it was worth.
dorishandy9801
December 26, 2025
"Slow response and no replacement"
I was trying to be patient, but wow, they took forever to get back to me. The toy arrived broken, which happens I guess, but then they still wouldn’t replace it after all that waiting. Kind of ridiculous, though I’m sure they’re usually fine or whatever. Just not a great experience for me.
James-fordham
December 20, 2025
"I ordered a Barbie set for…"
I ordered a Barbie set for a birthday and they literally sent me a completely different one. Customer support asked me to send photos, so I did, and then I had to wait all over again. When the replacement finally showed up, it was wrong too. Super frustrating, especially since it was supposed to be a gift. I won’t be ordering from mattel again.
denise.Mitchell
December 05, 2025
"I tried to buy something on mattel.com…"
I tried to buy something on mattel.com, but the whole experience was really frustrating. The site kept freezing and jumping around, the filters were a pain to use, and pages took forever to load. Checkout felt way more complicated than it needed to be, and at times the way things were explained almost made me feel talked down to, like I was the problem for not figuring it out faster. After about 20 minutes of dealing with it, I just gave up. Not a great shopping experience.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Mattel?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.